In hydraulic cylinders, sealing performance is affected by the properties of the surface it contacts as well as the seal material. Surface roughness, machining marks, and localized defects can alter the friction behavior with the oil film. The appropriate surface is determined according to the requirements of the relevant seal design and operating conditions.
Therefore, surface quality cannot be assessed solely based on whether it appears “glossy” or “smooth.” An average roughness value also does not explain the entire surface behavior. Technical inspection should utilize a combination of the measurement profile, measurement conditions, and evidence of damage.
Technical checklist
| Subject of review | What does it tell? | Why should they be read together? |
|---|---|---|
| Average roughness | A general summary of the profile. | It can conceal a local defect. |
| Hill and depression structure | Distribution of the contact surface. | It is related to the oil film and wear. |
| Processing direction | The direction of surface traces | Its effect varies depending on the direction of movement. |
| Scratches and coating defects | Local discontinuity | It can create problems regardless of the average value. |
How do the surface and the seal work together?
The seal makes controlled contact with the surface during movement. The oil film plays a role in the friction and wear behavior of this contact. Excessively sharp peaks on the surface, localized scratches, or an inappropriate machining direction can alter the designed contact condition.
A very low average value does not automatically imply superiority for every design. The sealing element's manufacturer's recommendations should be evaluated together with the movement speed, pressure, and fluid type. The goal is to create a surface characteristic suitable for the respective sealing system, rather than reducing all surfaces to the same number.
Why is a single average value limited?
Two surfaces may have the same average roughness value, but their peak and trough structure may differ. One surface may have a few deep scratches, while the other may have a more regular profile. The average value may not fully reflect this difference.
The surface report should describe the parameters used, including measurement direction, evaluation length, and filtering conditions. Directly comparing numbers obtained using different methods can be misleading. Assessing measurement uncertainty is particularly important for borderline results.
How to read a measurement report
First, determine which product surface the report pertains to. The requirements for the outer surface of a measuring device may not be the same as those for another inner surface. The product code, measurement location, and measuring device information must be included in the report.
Next, compare the results with the relevant drawing and the requirements for the sealing element. A lower number in one report does not necessarily mean better quality than another report obtained under different measurement conditions. Results can only be interpreted reliably when the methodology and acceptance criteria are consistent.
When is the surface investigated during a leak detection operation?
Even after installing a new gasket, recurring damage in a similar area may warrant a surface inspection. However, misalignment, contamination, and improper assembly should also be investigated beyond the surface. The location of the damage mark on the gasket can be compared to the location of the mark on the surface.
In a hypothetical example, let's consider long scratches on one side of the step. These marks indicate surface damage; however, they do not alone explain the source of the damage. Possibilities such as contaminant particles, assembly, or lateral loads need to be ruled out. Photographing the findings before cleaning the disassembled parts supports the investigation.
Why on-site polishing is not a general solution.
Uncontrolled surface modifications can alter the diameter, coating thickness, or surface profile. A surface that appears brighter may not meet the sealing requirements. Repair limits should be determined by the product design and the manufacturer's acceptance method.
If surface retreatment is decided upon, post-treatment dimensional, profile, and necessary coating checks should be carried out simultaneously. A short-term reduction in leakage alone does not indicate that the repair is suitable under all conditions.
How is this reflected in procurement and service decisions?
Instead of requesting a single generic number for all surfaces during the purchase process, define the critical surface requirement with a technical drawing. During servicing, gather the product code, damage photos, used gasket, and operating conditions in a single file.
A technical evaluation conducted using the Hidromas cylinder family and the relevant model ensures that surface findings are addressed within the correct product context. Examining the surface, seal, and assembly relationship together leads to a more consistent investigation of recurring sealing problems.
Choose the measurement location according to the function of the surface.
The area working with the gasket in the cylinder, the contact surface, and another machined area do not perform the same function. If the measured location is not specified in the surface report, a correct number may have been used for the wrong surface. The critical contact area and measurement direction should be indicated in the inspection plan. If only a specific stroke range is operated during use, the difference between the worn section and the under-operated section can also contribute to the investigation.
Selecting measurement points only from visually appealing locations reduces the representativeness of the results. If a local defect is suspected, both that area and a suitable reference area for comparison can be examined. However, a single profile taken from the defect does not represent the average production quality of the entire part. It should be clear whether the report is prepared for production acceptance or damage investigation purposes.
Investigate the timing of the leak complaint.
Whether the leak occurs immediately after assembly, after a certain operating period, or only during a cold start is an important distinction. In the first case, assembly damage or part mismatch may be the primary concern; in subsequent use, surface changes, contamination, or other operational effects are investigated. These possibilities are not definitive diagnoses. The timing of the complaint helps determine which investigation should be performed first.
When evaluating the relationship between the surface and the seal, the seal code and oil information used should also be recorded. A different seal element appearing to be the same size may not have the same surface requirements. If the seal material or design has been changed during maintenance, it must be verified that the previous acceptance condition is still valid. Attributing the problem solely to the metal surface may overlook the effect of the changed seal element.
Determine the cause of surface damage before considering a repair method.
Longitudinal scratches, circumferential marks, and localized impacts can all constitute different investigation areas. The direction of the marks, seal damage, and findings on the guide surfaces are evaluated together. If contacting contaminant particles or alignment problems persist, surface resurfacing may only provide temporary improvement. The goal of repair is not to restore the surface to a polished state, but to restore the operating condition required by the design.
If the part is found suitable for reprocessing after authorized inspection, the diameter and coating limits should also be checked after processing. Exceeding dimensional tolerances while adjusting roughness is not an acceptable outcome. Necessary checks should not be used interchangeably. Storing the before and after measurements of the repaired part under the same product ID provides more reliable data for future service decisions.
Request comparable surface proof from the supplier.
When evaluating the surface report of two products, ensure that the measurement parameters, orientation, and evaluation conditions are common. A lower number from different methods should not be directly converted to a better product result. The manufacturer's defined limit for the relevant seal and product design should be used as the basis. A general-purpose surface table cannot be applied equally to every cylinder.
During the Hidromas technical consultation, it is helpful to explain the surface requirements along with the product's operating speed, stroke usage, and environmental conditions. In the service request, the leak area, visible traces, and previous interventions should be specified. Thus, surface measurement can be used not only as a quality label but also as technical data explaining why the sealing system is functioning correctly or incorrectly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a glossy surface necessarily the right surface?
No. Brightness is a visual impression. Size, roughness profile, and localized defects should be assessed by measurement.
Could a single roughness value be sufficient?
Acceptance criteria depend on the application. Profile specifications and measurement methods may also be required for critical sealing surfaces. The gasket manufacturer's specifications and product drawing should be taken as the basis.
Does every scratch require cylinder replacement?
The decision depends on the location and size of the scratch, the condition of the coating, and the extent of the repair. A general decision about replacement or repair should not be made based solely on a photograph.
Technical resources
1. Hidromas telescopic cylinder product family
2. NIST measurement uncertainty assessment
Hidromas products and technical support
Last Posts
- Is it better to overhaul or replace a hydraulic cylinder?
- How are pressure, flow rate, and temperature interpreted together in hydraulic fault diagnosis?
- Why Sensor Accuracy and Calibration are Important in Hydraulic Pressure Measurement
- Tipper Body Creeping Down: Cylinder or Valve Leakage?
- How to Evaluate Flow Rate Loss Under Load in a Hydraulic Pump






